What makes a business the first choice?

First choice for what, and for whom?

A business does not need to be everybody’s favourite to have a valuable position. It needs to understand the situations in which it wants to be considered and the people involved in that decision. The same capability can matter for different reasons. An established company may value a partner’s experience because a project is politically sensitive. Another may need reassurance that an unfamiliar type of work can be delivered. A third may be buying access to judgement it does not have internally.

“Experienced team” could describe all three. It does very little to explain why that experience matters now.

This is why I would start with a buying situation rather than a list of adjectives or a polished description of an ideal customer.

Recognising the problem is different from deciding to deal with it.

Someone can recognise the problem on your website and still decide to do nothing because it does not feel urgent, another option seems sufficient or they cannot justify the expenditure. They might like your approach while remaining unsure what an initial engagement would actually involve. Understanding that hesitation is part of understanding the choice.

The brand has several jobs here. Help the customer understand why the issue matters, show how your offer relates to it and provide evidence that makes the proposed choice reasonable. Make it easy to find the information and take the next step. This does not mean manufacturing urgency. If the consequence of doing nothing is small, or you are not the right answer, pressure is a poor substitute for relevance.

Look at the alternatives the customer actually considers.

Your closest competitor on paper may not be the strongest alternative in the decision. For a professional service, the customer may do it internally, continue with an existing supplier, buy a narrower piece of work or delay the decision. Those alternatives have advantages, including familiarity and lower immediate effort. You need to understand what someone believes they gain by choosing you and what they believe they risk. Here is an illustrative example, not a client project. Imagine an engineering consultancy helping a manufacturer assess whether an existing facility can support a proposed production change.

The second column is familiar because it is easy to write. The third asks the business to make its value assessable.

Help your buyer explain the choice to someone else.

The person reading your website may also need to explain the decision to a founder, finance director, procurement team or other colleagues. A useful proposition gives them enough to describe the situation they need help with, why your offer fits, what makes your business credible and what the first commitment would enable them to decide or do.

That is one reason case studies need more than finished work and praise. Explain what the client was trying to achieve, the decision your work supported and what you actually contributed. If a result is reported, state who reported it and what you can reasonably infer. Evidence becomes more useful when its relevance is clear. A photograph, testimonial or statistic should answer a question the buyer has, rather than merely decorate the claim.

People need to recognise you and know how to buy.

Understanding the customer does not mean rewriting the business for every visitor. People also need to recognise you across encounters and find a coherent offer when they are ready. Your name, identity, language and recurring associations help connect those encounters. Your distribution, website structure, enquiry route and response matter to whether interest becomes a practical option. A compelling proposition that the right buyers never encounter cannot do much work. Neither can a prominent brand that makes it difficult to understand how to engage.

This is also why customer focus should not become an arbitrary rule to ignore everyone outside a very narrow profile. Make informed choices about relevance and commercial fit. Keep testing the assumptions behind them.

Find out why people actually chose you.

Treat the reason you hope customers will give as a hypothesis until you have heard what happened in real buying decisions. Begin with three clients whose engagements you would like more of, chosen for the quality and relevance of the work rather than the likelihood of a flattering answer, and ask about the actual decision to hire you.

Ask them to talk you through the sequence, including what happened just before the decision, who else was involved and what nearly prevented it. Keep their reasons for hiring you separate from what they appreciated afterwards, because both matter but answer different questions. You will learn more if you let them find their own words before explaining the proposition you hoped they would recognise.

Then test what your website communicates.

Show the relevant page to two credible target prospects without introducing your preferred explanation first. Let them explore, then ask:

Practical component

Your notes stay on this page and are not sent to Kiki. Copy or print them before you leave.

1. “What would you bring this business in to help with?”
2. “What would have to be happening in your business for you to contact them?”
3. “What would you still need to know before considering it seriously?”

Those questions test comprehension and initial relevance. They do not establish that someone would buy. A polite “looks great” is not the same as a credible answer about what they would commission and why. Record what each person understood, the evidence they noticed and where they hesitated. If they struggle to explain the first engagement, the issue may be the offer. If they understand it but cannot see why your business is credible, the proof may need work.

Three clients and two prospects give you early qualitative evidence. The sample is small, selected and shaped by existing relationships. It cannot tell you how the whole market thinks. Add lost opportunities, people who chose another route and further customer research as the decision warrants.

Use what you learn to explain why people choose you.

Write a short buying story using the evidence you have. When this situation happens, these customers need to achieve this outcome. They consider these alternatives. They choose us for these reasons. We can substantiate those reasons with this evidence. The first commitment enables this next decision or action. Mark any unproven sentence as an assumption. That gives you a better basis for deciding what to say, what to show and what still needs investigating. Becoming the first choice starts with taking the customer’s choice seriously. Build an offer that matters, make the reasons visible and ensure the experience gives people reason to believe them again.

Back to top